Quick Answer: Unfair treatment in the workplace is only unlawful in Australia when it is tied to something the law protects, such as a protected attribute, a workplace right, union membership, or when it amounts to repeated bullying that risks your health and safety. A manager who is harsh, inconsistent or a poor communicator is not breaking the law by itself. Work out which category your situation falls into first, because that decides whether you go to the Fair Work Commission, an anti-discrimination body, or back to your employer.
In this guide
- What Counts as Unfair Treatment in the Workplace
- Unfair Treatment at Work Is Not Always Unlawful
- Reasonable Management Action, and Why It Defeats Most Complaints
- When Unfair Treatment at Work Crosses Into Unlawful
- Unfair Treatment and Unfair Discrimination Are Not the Same Thing
- Which Complaint Path Fits Your Situation
- Unfair Dismissal: Who Can Apply and the 21-Day Limit
- When Repeated Unfair Treatment Becomes a Safety Issue
- How to Build a Record of Unfair Treatment at Work
- How to Raise Unfair Treatment With Your Employer
- What the Complaint Data Says About Your Chances
- How to Deal With Unfair Treatment in the Workplace: Where to Start
- Frequently Asked Questions
Most people searching for help with unfair treatment at work are not asking a legal question. They are asking whether what is happening to them is normal, whether anyone will take it seriously, and whether there is anything they can actually do about it.
The honest answer is that a lot of unfair treatment at work is lawful. That is not a comfortable thing to read, but knowing it early saves you from building a case on ground that will not hold, and it points you at the parts of your situation that genuinely do have a remedy.
What Counts as Unfair Treatment in the Workplace
Unfair treatment at work is an everyday phrase rather than a legal one. People generally mean one of a handful of things: being singled out, being held to standards nobody else is held to, losing shifts or opportunities without explanation, being managed by someone who shouts, or being performance managed out of a job they were doing adequately.
Some of that is unlawful. Much of it is not. Australian workplace law does not give you a right to be managed well, to be liked, or to be treated the same as every colleague. It gives you specific protections, and your situation either touches one of them or it does not.
So the useful first question is not “is this unfair?” It is “is this unfair for a reason the law recognises?”
Unfair Treatment at Work Is Not Always Unlawful
This is the part most guides skip, and it is the part that saves you time.
An employer is generally entitled to allocate work as it sees fit, to set and change reasonable standards, to restructure, to promote one person over another, and to manage performance. A decision can be badly reasoned, poorly communicated and deeply unfair in the ordinary sense of that word while remaining entirely lawful.
What turns unfair treatment into something actionable is a connection.
The treatment has to connect to a protected attribute, to a workplace right you used, to union membership or activity, to a dismissal that was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, or to repeated conduct that puts your health and safety at risk.
Without one of those connections, there is usually no external remedy, however unreasonable the behaviour was.
That is worth knowing before you lodge anything, because an application that fails on this point can take months to fail.
Reasonable Management Action, and Why It Defeats Most Complaints
If your complaint involves a manager, this concept will decide it.
Australian law carves out reasonable management action carried out in a reasonable way.
The Fair Work Commission treats the following as management action rather than mistreatment: starting a performance management process such as a performance improvement plan, taking disciplinary action for misconduct, telling a worker their performance is not satisfactory, telling a worker their behaviour is not appropriate, asking a worker to perform reasonable duties, and acting to maintain reasonable workplace standards.
So being put on a performance improvement plan is not, on its own, unfair treatment in any legal sense. Being told your work is below standard is not either.
There is a second half to the test that matters just as much. Action that is reasonable in substance can still be unreasonable in the way it is carried out.
A performance conversation held in front of the team, or a disciplinary process that gives you no chance to respond, can fail the “reasonable manner” limb even though the underlying decision was legitimate.
If your complaint is really about how something was done rather than whether it was done, say so in those terms, because that is the question that gets tested.
When Unfair Treatment at Work Crosses Into Unlawful
There are four doors, and your situation needs to fit through at least one.
It was because of who you are
The Fair Work Act protects employees from adverse action taken because of race, colour, sex, sexual orientation, age, physical or mental disability, marital status, family or carer’s responsibilities, pregnancy, religion, political opinion, national extraction, social origin, breastfeeding, gender identity, intersex status, and experiencing family and domestic violence. If the unfair treatment traces back to one of these, it is discrimination and has its own pathway.
It was because you exercised a workplace right
General protections cover using or proposing to use a workplace right, making a complaint or inquiry about your employment, taking part in a dispute process, or asking about your pay. Adverse action taken for those reasons is unlawful. Adverse action here means being dismissed, having your job changed to your disadvantage, being treated differently from other employees, or not being hired.
It was because of union membership or activity
Freedom of association protects the right to belong or not belong to an industrial association and to take part or not take part in industrial activity.
It was repeated and it risks your health and safety
That is the bullying pathway, covered below.
The Act also prohibits coercion, undue influence or pressure on your conditions of employment, and knowingly or recklessly misleading you about your workplace rights.
Unfair Treatment and Unfair Discrimination Are Not the Same Thing
People often search for “unfair discrimination”, and the two words together cause confusion worth clearing up.
In Australian law, discrimination is already the unlawful category. There is no separate lesser offence of “fair” discrimination, so the word unfair adds nothing legally. What it usually signals is that the person is not sure whether their situation is discrimination at all.
The practical test is simple. If you can name the protected attribute the treatment relates to, you are dealing with discrimination, and the guide to how to deal with discrimination in the workplace as an employee sets out the complaint pathways, deadlines and evidence in detail.
If you cannot name one, you are dealing with unfair treatment, and this guide is the right starting point. The 12 common types of workplace discrimination is a useful checklist if you are unsure which category you are in.
Which Complaint Path Fits Your Situation
| If the unfair treatment is | Where it goes | Key limit |
|---|---|---|
| Tied to a protected attribute | Australian Human Rights Commission, or your state or territory anti-discrimination body | The Commission President may terminate a complaint lodged more than 24 months after the conduct |
| Adverse action for using a workplace right | Fair Work Commission, general protections | 21 days from the day after dismissal, where a dismissal is involved |
| A dismissal that was harsh, unjust or unreasonable | Fair Work Commission, unfair dismissal | 21 days from the dismissal, with minimum service requirements |
| Repeated behaviour creating a health and safety risk | Fair Work Commission, stop bullying order | You must still be employed and at ongoing risk |
| None of the above | Your employer’s own grievance process | Set by your employer’s policy |
If you are handling this from the other side of the desk, the employer and manager guides cover those duties.
Unfair Dismissal: Who Can Apply and the 21-Day Limit
If the unfair treatment ended in you losing your job, this is usually the strongest route, and it has the tightest deadline.
A dismissal is unfair if it was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, if it was not a genuine redundancy, or, for a small business, if it did not follow the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code. The Commission looks at whether there was a valid reason and whether you were given a chance to respond.
Three eligibility conditions apply. You must have completed the minimum employment period, which is 6 months, or 12 months if your employer is a small business with fewer than 15 employees counted by head count including regular casuals.
You must be covered by the national workplace relations system. And you must be covered by an award or enterprise agreement, or earn less than the high income threshold.
The deadline is 21 days from the dismissal. Miss it and the application is usually out of time regardless of how strong it was.
One thing to note if you work for a small business. If your employer can show it followed the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code, the Commission will find the dismissal fair. That is a real hurdle, not a formality.
When Repeated Unfair Treatment Becomes a Safety Issue
Bullying is the pathway people most often overlook, and it is the one that does not require a protected attribute at all.
A worker is bullied at work when an individual or group repeatedly behaves unreasonably towards them and that behaviour creates a risk to health and safety.
Two elements do the work there. It has to be repeated, so a single incident will not qualify, and it has to create a risk, not merely be unpleasant. Reasonable management action carried out in a reasonable way is excluded.
To apply to the Fair Work Commission for an order to stop bullying you need to be a worker in a constitutionally covered business, believe you have been bullied more than once, believe the behaviour will continue, and believe it creates a risk to your health and safety.
The order is forward looking, which means it is designed to stop behaviour that is still happening. If you have already left the job, this route is generally closed to you.
How to Build a Record of Unfair Treatment at Work
Whichever door you end up at, the record decides the outcome, and unfair treatment cases live or die on pattern rather than on any single incident.
Keep a dated log somewhere your employer cannot access. For each event, note the date and time, who was present, what was said or done as close to the actual words as you can manage, and what changed as a result.
Then collect the unglamorous documents: rosters, timesheets, position descriptions, performance reviews, emails confirming decisions, and any policy your employer has published.
These matter more than you expect, because they let you show that the treatment you received differs from how others were treated, or from how the policy says it should have gone.
Two cautions. Do not take documents you are not entitled to have, because it creates a separate problem that can swallow your complaint. And check your state or territory law before recording a conversation, since the rules on recording without consent differ across Australia.
How to Raise Unfair Treatment With Your Employer
For treatment that is not unlawful, your employer’s own process is the only route, so it is worth using properly rather than as a formality.
Find the grievance or complaint policy and follow what it says. Put the complaint in writing even if you raise it in conversation first, and keep a copy outside work systems. Describe behaviour and its effects rather than character. “I was the only person not told about the roster change, and it happened three times in six weeks” lands. “My manager has it in for me” does not.
State the outcome you want. Most grievance processes fail because nobody said what resolution would look like. And if there is a union, an employee representative or an employee assistance program available, use them. You are not expected to do this alone.
What the Complaint Data Says About Your Chances
Two numbers are worth knowing before you commit to an external process.
The first is about where complaints come from. Of the 2,562 complaints the Australian Human Rights Commission received in 2022-23, employment accounted for 78% of sex discrimination complaints and 62.5% of age discrimination complaints, against 36% for race and 34% for disability. Workplace complaints are the Commission’s core business, so you are not an outlier for raising one.
The second is about how they end. The Australian National Audit Office found that conciliation resolved 46% of complaints in 2017-18 but only 33% by 2023-24, against the Commission’s own 40% target, while complaints terminated, declined or discontinued rose from 40% to 58% over the same period. Timeliness moved the same way, with the share finalised within 12 months falling from 98% to 72%.
Read together, the message is not that external processes are pointless. It is that they are slower and less likely to produce an agreed outcome than they were five years ago, which is a strong argument for getting your record in order and giving the internal process a genuine run first.
How to Deal With Unfair Treatment in the Workplace: Where to Start
Four steps, in this order.
- Write down what happened, with dates, and store it outside your work accounts.
- Work out which category you are in. Protected attribute, workplace right, dismissal, repeated conduct risking your safety, or none of these.
- If a dismissal is involved, check the date immediately, because the 21-day clock is already running.
- Raise it internally in writing, and get advice from your union, a community legal centre or an employment lawyer before lodging anything external.
Organisations that handle this well tend to have the same three things in place before anyone complains: a policy people can actually find, training that is current, and a reporting channel that leads somewhere. Sentrient’s workplace compliance system and online compliance courses are built for exactly that.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is unfair treatment at work illegal in Australia?
Not by itself. It becomes unlawful when it connects to a protected attribute, to a workplace right you exercised, to union membership or activity, to a dismissal that was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, or to repeated conduct that creates a risk to your health and safety.
2. What is the difference between unfair treatment and discrimination?
Discrimination is unfair treatment connected to a protected attribute such as age, sex, race or disability. Unfair treatment with no such connection is not discrimination, and it generally has no external remedy unless another protection applies.
3. Is being put on a performance improvement plan unfair treatment?
Generally no. Starting a performance management process is listed as reasonable management action. It can still be challenged if the way it was carried out was unreasonable, for example if you were given no opportunity to respond.
4. What is “unfair discrimination”?
It is not a separate category in Australian law. Discrimination on a protected attribute is already unlawful, so the word unfair adds nothing legally. People usually use the phrase when they are unsure whether their situation counts as discrimination at all.
5. How long do I have to act?
If you were dismissed, 21 days from the dismissal for an unfair dismissal or general protections application to the Fair Work Commission. For federal discrimination complaints, the Commission President may terminate a complaint lodged more than 24 months after the conduct. State and territory limits are set separately and are often shorter.
6. Can I apply to stop bullying if I have already resigned?
Generally no. A stop bullying order is designed to prevent behaviour that is continuing, so it requires you to still be at risk. If you have left, other avenues may apply depending on why you left.
7. Does my employer have to treat everyone the same?
No. Employers can treat employees differently for legitimate reasons such as role, performance, experience or business need. The law intervenes when the difference is based on something protected, or when the conduct meets the bullying test.
8. What if my manager is just a poor communicator?
That is rarely actionable externally on its own, but it is squarely within your employer’s grievance process, and it is worth raising there. Document specific incidents and their effects rather than describing a general style.
This guide is general information about Australian workplace law and is not legal advice. Eligibility, time limits and protections differ between jurisdictions and change over time. For advice on your own situation, speak to your union, a community legal centre or an employment lawyer.
Sources
Fair Work Commission, Reasonable management action
Fair Work Ombudsman, Protections at work (general protections)
Fair Work Commission, Minimum employment period
Australian Human Rights Commission, Annual Report 2022-23 complaint statistics
Last reviewed: October 2026
